Personal work / Writing

Snooki and the Hero’s Journey

Collage of Snooki photos on leopard print with a New Jersey license plate and a glitter rose

Whether you kept up every Jerzday or kept your distance, I think we can all agree that MTV’s Jersey Shore is a cultural phenomenon. Each member of the Jersey Shore House gave us a glimpse into the culture – all guided by our dear Snooki, otherwise known as Nicole LaValle (née Polizzi). At the time of the first season, I was a 14-year-old growing up in the Midwest, and I couldn’t relate to these people at all. For one, I wasn’t Italian. For another, I was ten years younger than most of them. But for some reason, I felt drawn to Snooki. Her social blunders felt relatable, and her enthusiasm for partying was something I could aspire to. I could see myself in her – maybe it’s because we were both the youngest girl in a family. She was relentlessly bullied, not by an older brother, but by American media through things like South Park’s famed “Snooki want smoosh smoosh” scene, tabloid rumors of anorexia, and the meme-ification of the photos of her arrest. In spite of the hate she received, she became a pop culture icon, and watching it happen was nothing short of inspiring to those of us also getting bullied – maybe my path could be like hers. Through her storyline, character development, and growth, Snooki found herself and her place within guido culture and took us along for the ride. She cemented herself as the main character of the show’s first season, and thanks to the high school English classes I was in while watching it, I found a connection between Snooki’s journey and Joseph Campbell’s Hero’s Journey.

Before we get too far into this, let me get you up to speed on the series, its heroine, and the framework of her journey: Jersey Shore was a reality TV show that debuted in 2009 and focused on a group of eight young Italian-Americans spending their summer in Seaside Heights, New Jersey, in what’s called a “Shore House.” As defined in the pilot, a shore house is ”six to ten people – it’s crazy, you have strangers living with you the whole summer – the nightlife, the girls – guidos everywhere, hot girls, and house music.” Snooki joined the show as the youngest member of the cast, just a few months shy of her 22nd birthday. She, like her housemates, identified as a guido, or guidette – a subculture characterized by an affinity for being fit, having tanned skin, and partying to house music. Originally a negative term for a stereotype against Italian-Americans, Snooki and her roommates wore the term as a badge of pride.

The Hero’s Journey is a structure identified by Joseph Campbell in the 1940’s that can be seen in heroic tales from multiple cultures across time. All of these stories follow the same basic structure: separation, initiation, and return. Campbell found other elements in the patterns of these stories, like a call to adventure, a guide or spiritual aid that helps the hero, and the bestowal of a gift.2 You’ll see this structure in mythical tales like Homer’s Odyssey, modern stories like The Matrix, and naturally, the first season of Jersey Shore.

Our heroine’s call to adventure is when she joins the cast of Jersey Shore, and we’re introduced to her in the pilot. The first act of the episode gives us an introduction to shore houses and guido culture spoken by each cast member. Snooki’s segment gives us the least amount of information. Interestingly, she’s given less screen time than the rest of the cast. She’s shown to have an appreciation and respect for guido culture and wants to be a part of it, however, she isn’t able to explain what we, the viewers, nor she, herself, should expect. This storytelling is left to her roommates who are more familiar with the concept of a shore house and already had footage of themselves partying to share with the show’s producers. Instead, Snooki is presented as someone wishing to join the culture. She wants to marry a guido, move to New Jersey, and live her life. She’s never been away from home before, and what better way to start than a summer at the shore?

When Snooki arrives at the shore house, she meets her roommates – three women and four men each with a nickname and a thirst for partying. They come from different walks of life and different parts of the northeastern US, but they all have something in common: they’ve found their place within guido culture.

  • Jennifer Farley (JWoww, or Jenni) is a stoic who is quick to lock herself down in a relationship. She introduces herself as having “a bad habit of playing little emotional games with men” (S1 E1) and gives little grace to herself or her desires. She joins the shore house with a boyfriend, which shows us a key practice of a woman in this culture: she calls her boyfriend when she gets home from the club, regardless of the time, so he knows she didn’t hook up with a guy. She repeats this and many other exhausting habits in her relationship, which gradually becomes more and more toxic, but endures it because she’s not sure if she’s able to be alone – “Me, single? That’s bad.” (S1 E3) Tragically, she’s found herself within a patriarchal structure that she finds comfort in.
  • Samantha Giancola (Sammi Sweetheart) has a clear understanding of her identity. In her introduction, she gives us the definition of a guidette: “somebody who knows how to club it up, takes really good care of themselves, has pretty hair and cakes on makeup, has tanned skin, wears the hottest heels – pretty much know how to own it and rock it.” Her vanity is her strength – she spends a large amount of her time getting ready for events by doing her makeup, straightening her hair, and choosing outfits. At some point, she’s late to meet Ronnie’s parents because of this, but in turn, it’s a display of her power. She uses her appearance as a form of posturing, showing hostility toward any woman she sees as a threat.
  • Angelina Pivarnick (whose nickname is supposedly “Jolie”, but it doesn’t stick) is loud and outgoing. She singles people out and speaks to them, demanding attention. She’s a shit-stirrer and creates the drama she wants to experience. She’s a liar, lazy, and self-righteous – but she’s exciting, and furthermore, good TV. She’s able to command attention unlikely anyone else in the house. Her facial expressions and yelling get her point across, whether or not if she’s right. She’s so stubborn that she decides not to work at the shore store, the novelty t-shirt shop the cast is required to work at in exchange for lodging at the shore house, and is kicked out of the house and subsequently, the show.
  • Michael Sorrentino (The Situation, or simply, Mike) is a clear example of a patriarch within guido culture – his goal every night is to meet women, bring them home, and smash (S1 E1). Thankfully, he isn’t plagued by the double standard that women are for sleeping with multiple partners. He cooks for the household and serves a Sunday dinner every week, preparing enough food to feed the housemates, the filming crew, and then some. He frequently calls himself the leader of the house, and his roommates certainly look to him that way by never questioning his actions. Mike’s trademark abs drew the attention of women at each of the clubs they attended, from Seaside Heights to Florence, Italy, and earned him a place on the Wikipedia page for the term “guido.”
  • Ronald Ortiz-Magro (Ronnie) is known for his fights with Sammi, who he begins dating in episode 2. Aggression seems to be his preferred method of dealing with stress and confusion. He doesn’t want to feel stupid, so he works out and juices himself to make sure he’s the most jacked person in any argument. He resorts to posturing as an offensive gesture. Unfortunately, his aggression is also the way he shows affection. Like a wolf, if anything happens to a member of his pack, he’ll use violence to defend their honor. He lets his body do the work for him, whether he wants to intimidate other men or lure in women – “First impression is everything. Everywhere you go you’re always making a first impression on somebody.” (S1 E1) Much like Sammi, his appearance is his asset, and for Ronnie, this is both the way he looks and the way he is seen.
  • Paul DelVecchio’s (Pauly D’s) confidence is the key to his success. He’s the oldest of the group and certainly the least concerned about what others think of him. Pauly never feels threatened, rarely gets in fights, and brushes off most incidents with a laugh. He’s presented first in the show’s introduction, so he’s our first example of guido culture. “I was born and raised a guido. It's just a lifestyle; it's being Italian, it's representing family, friends, tanning, gel, everything.” (S1 E1) He doesn’t have the Cadillac logo tattooed on himself for anyone other than Pauly D.
  • Vincent Guadagnino (Vinny) is the most culturally Italian of the bunch. Raised in an Italian family on Staten Island, he’s already enjoyed large multi-course pasta dinners and summers at the shore. Though he’s nearly the same age as Snooki, he’s already significantly more familiar with guido culture through his relatives and knows what to expect out of his summer. He enters the house making snide comments at the girls because he’s been raised to have high expectations of his first summer on the shore. He comes prepared, and because of this, he’s immediately pulled under the wing of Mike and Pauly, the two oldest and most experienced people in the house.

On the other hand, take Snooki, a 4’9” self-proclaimed “meatball”. She’s used to being the center of attention back home in Marlboro, NY, but her roommates are already shore house royalty. Her cross into the unfamiliar territory of the Shore House comes with many challenges. She doesn’t know where she fits into this group or guido culture as a whole, but she does know how to party, so she runs with it. She gets drunk almost immediately, which isn’t taken well by the rest of her housemates. Her drunkenness escalates further until she’s shitfaced in the hot tub in her underwear, trying to hook up with Mike. After she passes out, the rest of the roommates head out to the boardwalk to bond and enjoy the first night of their summer at the shore, getting a head start in their friendship. Snooki comes to alone at the house, feeling foolish, and calls her dad to express regret. It gets worse the following morning when she wakes up, spends the morning getting sick, and is late to her first day of work at the t-shirt shop. Embarrassed, she confronts the cast back at the house to understand why she’s being excluded, but their response is less than reassuring – Sammi doesn’t want Snooki’s “pukey breath on [her].” (S1 E1) She’s “on the outcast (sic)” and wants to go home.

Compared to the hostile, masculine energy among her housemates, Snooki brings emotional tenderness, self-reflection, and positivity to the group. Her cheerful demeanor and thirst for a good time is a little excessive for the rest of her roommates. When she joins her roommates in the hot tub on her first night, matching their excited energy, they ask “What is she thinking?” – but when we see Jenni in the jacuzzi shortly after, there’s nothing wrong with it. Snooki is able to pinpoint her feelings and communicate her needs accurately, but based on Sammi’s definition of a guidette, this doesn’t quite fit into the culture and comes off as weak. Even in her drunken stupor away from the group, she mumbles something about “You don’t understand how I feel… how I [redacted] feel about all this [redacted].” She doesn’t quite fit the mold of the typical guidette, like Jenni, Sammi, or Angelina, so her male roommates see her as “sloppy” and a “drama queen,” and even Sammi calls her a “stupid bimbo.” Snooki, seeing that she’s made a bad first impression, publicly apologizes to her housemates during their first dinner together. Her apology is well-structured, acknowledges her behavior on the first night, and expresses gratitude to them for tolerating it. The roommates break into applause, Sammi verbally accepts Snooki’s apology, and she even gets a kiss on the cheek from Jenni. Despite all of this, we know that vulnerability is seen as a weakness in this culture. Though she’s been excused from her antics, this doesn’t make her a part of the family quite yet and Snooki continues struggling to integrate with her roommates.

When the men of the house bring a group of girls back from the club, Snooki overhears Angelina and Sammi making snide comments about the girls that she unknowingly believes are about her. She’s devastated and embarrassed, and she calls her dad to make plans to leave. Her roommates see this reaction as avoidant and impulsive, but instead, knowing Snooki, we can interpret her doing this to protect her peace. She has no business being there if she isn’t going to enjoy it. Sammi is the first to recognize that Snooki’s decision to leave is her clearest expression of self, which to her, presents as a strength. She encourages this self-expression which seems to be a turning point for Snooki, so she decides not to leave. Campbell describes a threshold separating the hero’s home world from the adventure world, and typically some presence guarding that barrier. We can see Snooki’s experience entering the shore house as no exception, with the housemates guarding the sanctity of their culture. Her integration into the house has been rocky, but Sammi is the guide that has pulled her further along in her journey.

Things finally start looking up for Snooki. Her mother comes to visit for a day, which lets Snooki recalibrate and remember why she decided to enter the shore house in the first place. She goes out with her roommates, flirts with men, and builds micro-connections with them for the night. She expresses disdain for not being able to “get it in” with these men, but regardless she’s more confident, in her element, and getting the attention she’s used to back in Marlboro. The housemates go out dancing to house music, and Snooki puts on a show of cartwheels and hair flips. Jenni is notably impressed and says that Snooki “came out the woodwork” (which, typically is a negative thing to say, but based on her tone we can interpret Jenni’s usage of this phrase as positive). The roommates are dancing, battling (read: dancing at each other), and slowly becoming a family. After a successful night at the club, the gang goes to a nearby bar to drink shots. They’re bonding and enjoying their evening until an unknown man starts taking the shots intended for the housemates. Snooki responds with confrontation, defending her newfound family. The housemates aren’t paying attention and aren’t too supportive of her until the man punches her squarely in the face.

Immediately, the cast assembles into her defense. The puncher is dogpiled on by the men of the house and removed from the bar with the swiftness and preparedness of the Secret Service protecting the president. The women of the house jump to Snooki’s aid and bring her to the bathroom to treat her wounds. The puncher is arrested as the castmates patrol the boardwalk looking for his friends, ready to strike in retribution. The housemates are heated, and it’s all for Snooki. They see her value as an independent member of the group, and now see her as one of their own. Joseph Campbell calls this part of the journey an “initiation”2 – she’s been struck by a colossus but has emerged triumphant.

This revelation encourages Snooki to, per Sammi’s definition, “own it and rock it” slowly and surely as the summer goes on. She becomes more willing to show her emotions to her castmates and express her feelings at times of tension. When Sam and Ron begin to spend less time with the rest of their roommates, Snooki expresses her feelings about it via a concise, structured platform. She’s unhappy but does the work to find a solution that can make everyone happy. When Mike makes fun of her weight, Snooki divulges her negative relationship with food to Jenni. This conversation helps her bond with her roommate and starts developing a friendship worthy of an MTV spinoff series. The cast teases her over the next few episodes, but after a conversation with Ronnie she understands the lighthearted motive behind their comments – she’s their younger sibling getting teased rather than defending herself from malice. She’s opened up, and her growing steadfastness in her emotions is now seen as a strength among her roommates. The other folks in the house, in turn, become closer to each other as well as with Snooki. Mike and Pauly would later affirm that Snooki’s assault, in a way, brought the house together. By the end of the summer, Snooki has been given Campbell’s prophesized gift – a new family.

Though she was only a 21-year-old from the tri-state area, she completed a journey of growth, strength, and discovery no less than heroes like Odysseus or Neo. She experienced a separation from her former life in Marlboro, an initiation into her new life as part of the Jersey Shore family, and a return home that spurred costumes for Halloween ‘09, young women copying her trademark “poof” hairstyle, and a strong comeback for leopard print. Her journey throughout this season increased viewership by nearly 50% after the climactic episode where she was punched and ultimately drove the show to success. Jersey Shore went on for five more seasons through 2012 and recently spurred a revival series, Jersey Shore Family Vacation. She joined the shore house with very little concrete knowledge of what it meant to be a guidette, but by the end has become one of the most recognizable guidettes in contemporary culture. Deena Cortese’s entrance in season 3 reinforced this, as she joined following the Snooki archetype – their first days were nearly identical (e.g. getting drunk, coming on to Mike, etc.), they fit the same niche in guido/guidette culture as emotion-driven individuals, and they were even both shunned by Sammi upon their entrance, later to be accepted into her circle. Deena and further iterations of the archetype would not exist without Snooki, and neither would Jersey Shore as a successful reality series. Jersey Shore could have happened with anyone, but it couldn’t have succeeded without Snooki.

I’ve rewatched Jersey Shore countless times since I was that 14-year-old in the Midwest, and I relate to it a little bit more every time. I’m still not Italian, but now I’m almost ten years older than Snooki was when the series began, and see a bit of her in my life since then. I, too, have embarrassed myself trying to impress an older group of potential friends, been excluded from a group for not fitting in a particular mold, and tried communicating my feelings to receive ire in response. Like Snooki, I ended up finding acceptance in my community and prioritized my emotional well-being – even though I didn’t turn out to be a guidette pop-culture sensation like her, I do feel like the hero of my own arc.

You too, reader, can rewatch the first season of Jersey Shore on Paramount+ or Hulu and make the connections between your young adulthood, Snooki’s journey, and Campbell’s Hero’s Journey.

← Back to personal work